Jonelle Matthews Death & Obituary: The disappearance of Jonelle Matthews, a 12-year-old girl from Greeley, Colorado, captivated the nation and left a community in despair for more than three decades. Her mysterious vanishing just days before Christmas in 1984 became one of the first cases to be widely publicized through the use of milk cartons, a desperate attempt to bring her home. It wasn’t until a grisly discovery by construction workers in 2019 that the long-cold case finally began to thaw, leading to the shocking arrest of her killer in 2020.
Who Was Jonelle Matthews?
Jonelle Matthews was the adopted daughter of Jim and Gloria Matthews and the younger sister of Jennifer, the Matthews’ biological daughter. Described as a strong-willed and spirited child, Jonelle had a presence that was impossible to ignore. “She was strong in everything,” her mother, Gloria, recalled in a 2019 interview. Jonelle was known for her physical strength, determination, and vibrant personality.
The Matthews family, deeply involved in their community and church, had moved frequently due to Jim’s work, but at the time of Jonelle’s disappearance, they had settled in Greeley. Jim was the principal at Platte Valley Elementary School, while Jonelle enjoyed typical childhood activities, such as riding bikes, attending sleepovers, and fawning over popular 1980s boy bands like Menudo. Her friend Deanna Ross remembered her as “very funny, loud, theatrical, and the center of the room,” capturing the essence of a girl who was full of life.
The Night of Jonelle’s Disappearance
The evening of December 20, 1984, was supposed to be a joyful one. Jonelle had performed Christmas carols with her middle school honor choir in an event that was even televised for a local cable network. Afterward, her friend Deanna’s father drove her home, dropping her off around 8 p.m. The garage door was partially open, but nothing seemed amiss at the time.
Jonelle settled in at home and answered a phone call, taking a message for her father, which indicated that she was still safe around 8:30 p.m. However, by the time her father Jim returned home an hour later, Jonelle was gone. The house was eerily undisturbed, with the television and heater still on, Jonelle’s stockings on the couch, and her shoes neatly placed aside.
Jim didn’t become concerned until his older daughter, Jennifer, returned home from a basketball game around 10 p.m. with no news of Jonelle’s whereabouts. A sense of dread quickly set in, and Jim called the police. Officers arrived and searched the home, but there was little evidence to guide them.
Strange footprints were found in the snow outside one of the windows, and it appeared that someone had attempted to cover their tracks with a rake. But beyond that, there were no immediate clues, and Jonelle’s whereabouts remained a mystery.
Conclusion: A Cold Case Finally Solved
For over 30 years, Jonelle Matthews’ disappearance haunted her family and the Greeley community. The lack of answers kept the case cold, but in 2019, construction workers unearthed human remains that were later confirmed to be Jonelle’s. This discovery reignited the investigation, ultimately leading to the arrest of her killer in 2020. While justice has finally been served, the memory of Jonelle Matthews continues to be a painful reminder of the tragedy that befell a vibrant young girl and the community that mourned her loss for decades.
Looking for a bar to make your new local hangout? Look no further than Smokin’ Cues, a hidden gem located in the heart of Stockbridge, GA. At our bar & restaurant, we’ve got you covered when it comes to a great time!
Come hear some great live music, catch some sports, have a few drinks, or just sit back and relax! At our pool hall, there’s always something to do.